 |
| Getty images; Tyler Le/BI |
For a brief moment, Matt Hutton thought he had cracked the code to the millennial version of the American dream. After years of saving, he bought a modest two-bedroom townhome just outside Denver in 2019 for $324,000. When pandemic-era interest rates collapsed to historic lows, he seized the opportunity to refinance, cutting his borrowing costs significantly. Then, as home prices soared, his equity ballooned. By August 2024, he sold the home for a tidy gain of about $150,000 in only five years. With that windfall in hand, Hutton and his wife set their sights higher: a larger, newly built single-family home on a premium lot with a sparkling kitchen, ample natural light, and serene views of a nearby lake.
But what started as a fairytale move quickly turned into a cautionary tale. The new home had its perks, but it came with invisible costs. The location added hours to Hutton’s weekly commute, and the sprawling neighborhood was still under construction, leaving him surrounded by noise, dust, and half-finished houses. Even the seemingly small frustrations like the constant whipping wind echoing around the property began to grate. Within months, the couple found themselves contemplating another move, a decision almost always fraught with financial risk given transaction costs and shifting market conditions.
What put the Huttons in an especially tight spot, however, wasn’t just timing or dissatisfaction. It was the deal they had struck with their builder: a mortgage rate buydown worth $30,000. Builders across the country had been deploying buydowns temporary or permanent subsidies that reduce the borrower’s interest rate as their secret weapon to keep sales alive in a high-rate environment. Instead of cutting sticker prices, builders dangled “discounted” financing terms to make homes more appealing. Buyers, enticed by lower monthly payments, often agreed to higher purchase prices under the assumption that they could refinance when rates eventually fell.
Only, rates haven’t meaningfully fallen. As of 2025, mortgage rates remain stubbornly above 6.5%, far higher than the 3% or even 4% levels buyers were hoping would return. That gamble has left thousands of homeowners with expensive properties, thin equity cushions, and limited options to sell without losing money.
The Rise of the Mortgage Buydown
To understand the mess, it’s worth looking at why buydowns surged in popularity in the first place. When rates spiked in 2022, buyers fled the market. Sellers particularly large builders were suddenly stuck with a glut of inventory. Cutting home prices outright was risky because price reductions ripple across entire neighborhoods, dragging down comparable values. Buydowns emerged as an elegant workaround: Builders could keep list prices high while offering buyers temporary relief on their monthly payments.
Permanent buydowns reduce the interest rate for the life of the loan. For example, dropping a $400,000 mortgage from 6.5% to 5% could save a buyer nearly $400 each month and more than $140,000 over 30 years. Temporary “2-1” buydowns, by contrast, lower the rate by two percentage points in the first year, one point in the second year, and then reset to the original rate. This structure can save buyers several thousand dollars in the early years, when household budgets are often tightest, while still allowing builders to market affordability without cutting their sticker price.
By late 2022, nearly three-quarters of major homebuilders reported offering buydowns. The strategy kept their sales pipelines alive, but it also laid the groundwork for today’s buyer’s remorse.
A Bet on Refinancing That Hasn’t Paid Off
The underlying assumption of many buydown deals was simple: “Marry the house, date the rate.” In other words, buyers were told not to worry too much about today’s higher interest rates because refinancing would soon be an option once the Federal Reserve eased monetary policy. But that promise has yet to materialize. Rates remain elevated, and the economic environment has made it unclear when or if cheaper refinancing opportunities will arrive.
For homeowners who used temporary buydowns in 2022 or 2023, reality is now setting in. Monthly mortgage bills are snapping back to their full amounts, just as equity growth has slowed. Nationwide home prices rose less than 2% over the past year, with cities like Austin, Houston, and Jacksonville actually seeing declines. Buyers in hot construction markets such as the Sun Belt face particularly steep competition as builders continue to roll out new properties with fresh incentives. In practice, that means existing owners like Hutton often have to slash prices or provide costly concessions just to stay competitive.
The Equity Trap
The consequences are stark. Some homeowners are discovering that they cannot resell their homes for what they originally paid. Others are forced to dip into savings or even bring cash to the closing table. Mortgage analysts like Rick Palacios Jr. of John Burns Research and Consulting have been warning for months that buyers relying on buydowns could face a “shock” when they try to reenter the market. If builders continue layering on bigger incentives with some now offering up to $60,000 per home resale buyers simply cannot match those terms.
That’s exactly what happened to Hutton. He listed his $800,000 home in 2024 but had to cut the asking price after tepid interest. Ultimately, he sold it for roughly what he had paid and only by agreeing to provide the new buyer with a $40,000 buydown package to match builder incentives on competing properties nearby. When the dust settled, the six-figure profit he had made on his first home was entirely wiped out. His agent even cut into her own commission to help cover closing costs. The couple now rents an apartment, licking their wounds and vowing not to “jump the gun” on their next purchase.
What This Means for the Housing Market
The broader picture is one of caution for both buyers and sellers. For builders, buydowns were a lifesaver during the slowdown, allowing them to maintain margins and protect neighborhood pricing. But for many individual buyers, they have become a trap one that inflates purchase prices while offering only temporary relief.
Industry experts suggest that permanent buydowns can still be beneficial if buyers plan to stay put for seven to ten years. Short-term incentives, however, are proving risky unless refinancing truly becomes viable. And while this isn’t a repeat of the adjustable-rate mortgage crisis that fueled the 2008 collapse buyers today still have to qualify for the higher payment the psychological and financial strain of seeing payments jump by hundreds of dollars each month is real.
Real estate professionals are already reporting an uptick in “buyer’s remorse.” Families who moved for lifestyle reasons bigger homes, new neighborhoods, or better school districts are finding themselves financially squeezed or unable to sell without losses. The lesson may be clear: In housing, incentives can blur the line between affordability and overextension.
The story of Matt Hutton underscores a harsh reality in today’s housing market: Betting on lower mortgage rates has become an expensive gamble. Builders may continue to use buydowns as a sales tool, but buyers need to carefully assess their long-term plans before taking the plunge. For those who expect to move within just a few years, the lure of lower initial payments may not outweigh the risk of being stuck with an inflated purchase price in a slowing market.
As mortgage rates remain elevated and new-home incentives grow even larger, the housing market is revealing a new divide between those who can wait out the turbulence and those forced to sell into it. For the latter, the American dream may feel more like a very costly lesson.
