Greece’s islands have long held a magnetic pull — crystalline seas, rugged coasts, whitewashed buildings, ancient ruins, vibrant culture. I’ve visited 27 of them over the past five years, sometimes returning, sometimes escaping quickly. But through all that travel, I’ve learned that not all islands are created equal. Some leave imprints of light, beauty, authenticity; others disappoint with crowds, inflated prices, or sameness.
This article is not a guide to all islands, nor an exhaustive ranking. It’s a reflection of what transforms a trip into something unforgettable, and what makes another feel forgettable. I’ll share the three islands I’d return to in a heartbeat — places that blend scenery, culture, and soul — and two I would likely leave off my itinerary next time. I’ll also outline what to look for when choosing which islands to visit, tips to avoid tourist traps, and how to make the most of lesser-known gems.
The Islands I’d Return to in a Heartbeat
These are the three islands that captured my heart — not just for their views, but for their rhythms, textures, contrasts, and quiet magic.
1. Milos
Milos is volcanic, dramatic, and surprisingly diverse. One of its best highlights is Sarakiniko Beach, where the volcanic rock has been sculpted into pale, smooth shapes, glowing under the sun, almost lunar in quality. The contrast of white rock and turquoise water feels otherworldly — and photographs only tell part of the story. The wind, the smell of salt, the silence broken by sea spray — you feel time slow.
Milos isn’t just about beaches. Driving the island reveals small fishing villages where renovated waterfront boathouses, jaw-dropping views, and hospitable tavernas make for nights you don’t want to end. Boat trips around the coast reveal hidden coves accessible only by water; some beaches have no taverna, no souvenir shop, just sea and sand. Staying in a waterfront boathouse in a village allows you to wake up to the sound of the water gently lapping, to have fresh fish at dinner, to feel the difference between “being somewhere beautiful for a photo” and “living in a place that infuses your rest”.
What makes Milos so return-worthy is the blend of contrasts — accessible luxury and rugged wilderness, lively tavernas but peaceful evenings, easy boat rides but quiet inland hikes. It’s large enough to offer variety, small enough to avoid feeling overrun if you avoid peak season.
2. Symi
Symi is one of the more subtle, refined Greek islands. It doesn’t scream for attention the way Mykonos or Santorini do. Instead, its delight lies in narrow alleys, pastel houses drifting down toward the harbor, quiet staircases that wind up cliffs, sweeping views over water that glimmer in a hundred shades of blue and green.
One of my favorite experiences in Symi was hiking Kali Strata — a stairway of hundreds of stone steps from the harbor up through Chorio (old town). Along the way there are views: boats below, island mountains across the sea, the scent of oregano and thyme. It’s physically demanding but emotionally generous — after the climb, the view feels earned, and lunch in a taverna perched above the gulf tastes like victory.
Another delight is how easy it is to hop via water taxi or boat to little beaches or other islets nearby. On some islands, you feel boxed in by tourist infrastructure; in Symi, the infrastructure feels lighter, more gracious. Even the busy parts feel elegant rather than overwhelming. The pace is gentler; evenings linger over dinner, the light fades slowly, and it’s easy to find ruins or quiet corners. For someone who wants beauty without theater, Symi is close to perfect.
3. Skiathos
If Milos is scenic and raw, and Symi is quiet and refined, Skiathos brings another flavor: joyous energy. Skiathos has broad beaches, excellent food, a party pulse that doesn’t crush the charm. It blends liveliness and nature in a way many islands promise but few deliver.
During the days you can explore its many beaches — some wide and touristier, others tucked into coves. Boat rides and bus rides show varying landscapes: pine forested hills, small hidden bays, olive groves. By evening, the culinary scene comes alive. I had some of my best Greek meals in Skiathos — fresh seafood, bright salads, slow cooking, generous servings mixed with local wine or ouzo. Sunset cocktails at seaside bars, outdoor movie screenings under the stars, local shops, friendly locals — all of it stitched together in a way that feels festive yet approachable.
What I appreciate most about Skiathos is that you can shift your tempo. If you want party, you find it. If you want calm, you hide in a bay or take a quiet walk before dawn. Not every traveler needs both, but for me, that flexibility turns “nice trip” into “trip I’ll remember”.
The Islands I’d Probably Skip Next Time
Not all islands leave magic. Some feel overhyped; others feel like they compete with their tour boats more than with the sea. Here are two I would likely leave off my itinerary now.
1. Mykonos
Mykonos is famous — and for good reason in terms of nightlife, glamour, beach clubs, Instagrammable scenes. But with fame comes cost, crowds, and noise. Many of the things that once made Mykonos appealing have shifted under the pressure of tourism: luxury brands, inflated prices, busy beaches, packed restaurants.
If you arrive expecting postcard views and a party atmosphere, you’ll get both — but also the stress of vendors, the traffic, the hunt for parking, the difficulty of finding moderately priced tavernas not overtly catering to tourists. The nightlife is dazzling, but it can also feel staged. The photo opportunities are great, but in many places you stand elbow to elbow with every other visitor holding a phone.
I don’t think you must skip Mykonos entirely — it can work well as a quick stop or part of a sailing itinerary — but staying several days? Less worthwhile for me. I prefer an island where I wake up and smell olive trees rather than sunscreen and booming music.
2. Kos
Kos surprised me with its contradictions. It has beautiful beaches, an international airport, easy transport connections. But it also leans heavily into tourist infrastructure, which sometimes feels like it dulls the character. The old town is charming in parts, but many of the scenic corners feel boxed in by souvenir shops or repetitive menus. Beaches are nice, but I found others more picturesque. The cost for “nice beach chairs + umbrella + drink” often feels high relative to the ambiance or views.
Also, when I’ve visited, the visual “wow” factor was less consistent. Sunsets fade into islands across the sea, but the coastline often lacks the drama of rock, cliffs, volcano, or hidden coves. If your priority is ease and amenities, Kos works. But if your priority is beauty, solitude, scenic surprise — I’d pick Milos, Symi, or Skiathos instead.
What Makes the Difference: What to Look for in a Greek Island
Beyond specific names, there are traits and patterns I’ve come to rely on when deciding whether an island will stay with me long after I leave.
Natural Landscape & Uniqueness
Is there something the island has that you won’t find just anywhere? Dramatic coastline, unusual rock formations, hidden coves, volcanic landscapes, rugged features. Sarakiniko in Milos is one of those features. Islands that feel interchangeable — similar beaches, similar tavernas, flat coastline or uniform architecture — tend to fade from memory.
Size & Accessibility
Smaller islands can feel charming, but sometimes accessibility (boat, ferry, flights) is difficult — which is part of the charm, but also risk. Larger islands with several villages or regions allow exploration and pace changes. Islands that are very difficult to reach, or whose internal transport is unreliable, tend to make itineraries stressful rather than restful.
Tourism vs Authenticity
High tourist traffic isn't automatically bad, but when it overwhelms local life, raises prices, degrades experience, that’s when it crosses a line. Authentic villages, local tavernas, less commercial promotion, fewer big chain hotels matter. If you can still walk down a street unbothered by souvenir stalls, hear local dialects, eat fresh regional food, that island stays vivid. When everything feels built for tourists, it begins to lose personality.
Amenities & Services
Even in quieter islands, some comforts go a long way: clean water, decent ferry connections, simple conveniences like grocery shops or pharmacies, stable infrastructure (electricity, roads). Knocking yourself out to enjoy scenery is one thing; fighting for basic services is another. An island that blends beauty with basic comfort is stronger in practice than one that requires endurance or compromise every hour.
Pace & Atmosphere
I’ve learned I prefer more islands where time moves slower in the evenings, where people linger over dinner, where boats are part of life but not the defining feature. Nights under stars, evenings watching fishing boats return, walking calm beaches at dawn — these moments matter. Islands whose rhythm feels frantic or overly curated often lose charm.
Tips to Avoid Tourist Traps & Make Best Choices
For anyone planning Greek island travel, especially trying to collect memories rather than photos, here are lessons from visiting dozens of islands.
-
Go off-peak or shoulder season: May, early June, September are often best. Fewer crowds, more welcoming locals, better rates.
-
Rent a car or scooter when possible: Some of the best beaches or viewpoints are unreachable without your own wheels. Public transport often misses hidden gems.
-
Boat trips matter: Many islands have coves or beaches only accessible by boat. Taking a private or small-group boat trip often reveals the soul of the place.
-
Stay in quieter villages: Not every night must be in “the party town.” One or two nights in that spot might be fun; but staying in smaller villages offers quiet, authenticity, slower pace.
-
Support local artisans, tavernas, producers: Buy honey, olive oil, bread from locals. Eat where locals eat. That improves your experience and helps preserve local character.
-
Expect variation: Even great islands have rough beaches, crowded spots, or tedious logistics. Accepting a mix helps set realistic expectations.
Reflection: What These Islands Taught Me
After 27 island visits, some recurring realizations:
-
The best memories = unexpected moments: watching sunrise alone on a near-empty beach; random conversations with fishermen; unplanned detours; food that comes from someone’s family kitchen, not a restaurant menu.
-
Beauty grows with context: how you get there, how you arrive, how much you explore and how much you let yourself wander without schedule.
-
Sometimes skipping a hyped island frees up more joy: less money spent, less time in lines, fewer frustrations.
-
Depth over breadth: staying longer in fewer good islands often yields richer memories than bouncing between many.
Islands That Stay With You
If I were to plan another Greek island trip now, Milos, Symi, and Skiathos would be at the top of the list. Their combination of natural wonder, personality, ease of access, food, and atmosphere make them places I return to in a heartbeat. Mykonos and Kos, charming in their own ways, now feel like places I’d see once more but not linger in they’ve offered what they offer, and I want to spend more time in places that surprise me in different ways.
Greek islands will always offer magic. But the real magic, for me, lives in the islands that beat at your senses—the ones that make you remember salt spray, olive trees, a lunch you’ll crave again weeks later, a quiet moment by dusk when light spills gold over the sea. Those are the ones worth the return journey.
